UPDATED: The Pending End of the "Up Is Down" Era
UPDATED with the answers and a very embarrassing admission
Helping a friend bubble wrap a large abstract painting the other day, I recalled how many times I've been in a studio of a painter who works in abstraction and had one of two experiences. Either it had been years since I had seen a particular abstract piece but upon noticing it again realized, often to the artist's surprise, that it was upside down (my one and only memory parlor trick) ... or ... I watched as the artist his/herself tried to recall which was the correct orientation of a piece. Together those experiences might suggest I find it odd that artists sometimes forget the orientation of an abstract piece, but my parlor trick is inconsistent enough that I actually totally empathize.
Toward that end, and as my parting gift to 2008 (what a wild and in so many ways awful year it's been), I offer the following highly irreverent quiz (with sincere apologies to the artists). Among these well known works, can you tell which is upside right and which is upside down? I've ordered them according to what I consider easiest to hardest and I should note that in a few instances the image has been cropped ever so slightly to remove a tell-tale signature or other indication:
A. Kasimir Malevich: (correct)

B: Georges Braque (Upside down)

C: Barnett Newman (upside down)

D: Jasper Johns (correct)

E: Jackson Pollock (correct)

F: Joan Miró (correction: Image that had been here was actually a parody of a Miró, NOT an actual Miro...my bad. What I get for taking short cuts). It was upside down, but I've deleted it to not further my offense to the parodying artist.
G: Wassily Kandinsky (correct)

H: Kasimir Malevich (upside down)

I'll post the answers next year.
Have a healthy, happy and prosperous 2009 everyone!
Helping a friend bubble wrap a large abstract painting the other day, I recalled how many times I've been in a studio of a painter who works in abstraction and had one of two experiences. Either it had been years since I had seen a particular abstract piece but upon noticing it again realized, often to the artist's surprise, that it was upside down (my one and only memory parlor trick) ... or ... I watched as the artist his/herself tried to recall which was the correct orientation of a piece. Together those experiences might suggest I find it odd that artists sometimes forget the orientation of an abstract piece, but my parlor trick is inconsistent enough that I actually totally empathize.
Toward that end, and as my parting gift to 2008 (what a wild and in so many ways awful year it's been), I offer the following highly irreverent quiz (with sincere apologies to the artists). Among these well known works, can you tell which is upside right and which is upside down? I've ordered them according to what I consider easiest to hardest and I should note that in a few instances the image has been cropped ever so slightly to remove a tell-tale signature or other indication:
A. Kasimir Malevich: (correct)

B: Georges Braque (Upside down)

C: Barnett Newman (upside down)

D: Jasper Johns (correct)

E: Jackson Pollock (correct)

F: Joan Miró (correction: Image that had been here was actually a parody of a Miró, NOT an actual Miro...my bad. What I get for taking short cuts). It was upside down, but I've deleted it to not further my offense to the parodying artist.
G: Wassily Kandinsky (correct)

H: Kasimir Malevich (upside down)

I'll post the answers next year.
Have a healthy, happy and prosperous 2009 everyone!
Labels: art quiz
21 Comments:
good god: they all seem very "upside down" to me (esp. the Braque) except for the Johns and the Miro.
happy new year!
jg
Believe it or not, the Miro is actually upside down (that's my only give away answer).
I should have known! tricky tricky...
I forget who it was that got me to turn my canvases (in progress) upside down in order to check for badly dealt-with areas ("blind spots"). I did that for years and years, but I don't anymore. It was fun and quite useful for a while.
Of course the only one I was absolutely sure was right side up was the Miro. Happy new year!
ɹɐǝʎ ʍǝu ʎddɐɥ
how did you do that?
¡ǝʇnɔ
ʇdıɹɔs ǝɥʇ punoɟ...puıɯɹǝʌǝu
They all look upside down to me except the Johns. Abstract painters still tend to paint gravity; the heavy red form in the 'upper right' of the Miro gives it away.
Happy new year!
Even songwriters sometimes forget the lyrics to their own songs so its more about memory and/or age rather than indiscriminate choices.....
happy new year!
One time, as art director at a small college magazine, I put several images of paintings upside down. The painter, a major contributor to the college's endowment who had submitted the transparencies unmarked, wanted my head!
Hope to see you all at Pocket Utopia" in January.
--Sharon @ Two Coats of Paint"
Ed, you devil.
I'm with PL: They all look upside down except the Johns. (The Johns is definitely right side up.)
Adding to Sharon's comment: I once had a short-lived experience with a Midwest dealer who did an exhibition catalog of my work; every image was printed upside down--except the one that wasn't in the show.
May our next trip around the sun come with great joy, good health, and--hey, why not ask?--fabulous opportunities, critical acclaim and boomtown sales.
They all look upside down
The power of suggestion, I guess.
OK, one other hint: 4 of them are NOT upside down.
Okay, Ed, I'll bite.
My guesses:
A Malevich up
B Braque down
C Newman down
D Johns up
E Pollock down
F Miro up (you gave me that one)
G Kandinsky up
H Malevich down
Happy New Year, everyone! Best of luck in 2009! May we all find our personal Eli Broad to donate to our cause!
good guesses Charles. two wrong.
I noted the Miro is "actually upside down" though.
Based on that, only one of your other guesses if off.
oops - you said the Miro was down!
Damn you, Winkleman!
Okay, okay. . . ummmm, lets see, four are down so . . .
switch the Miro with the Pollock.
C B
er, that should be "only one of your other guesses is off.
switch the Miro with the Pollock.
:-)
it looks like the Newman is the only one that's right....
anyway..Happy New Year
Pedrovel
I know the right answers :P
But gotta go to celebrate New Year!!
HAPPY NEW YEAR!!!!!!!
bettcha Pollock wouldn't know which way his goes.
Here's my guess
A. correct
B. upside down
C. upside down
D. correct
E. correct
F. upside down (that bird's eye fooled me at first)
G. upside down
H. correct
Happy New Year! Let's hope the country is right side up this year.
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home